x
Black Bar Banner 1
x

Welcome to Markethive

Commenting On A Written Article or Post

Posted by Mike Prettyman on January 31, 2015 - 6:21pm Edited 1/31 at 6:22pm

I have discovered that I don't understand how to properly comment on a blog post or any other post, Facebook etc.

I tried to comment on a few articles, it didn't matter where the articles were, I had a problem. I would start then stop, I had no idea what to write. As always, I went looking for an answer to my problem.

The first thing I found was that “comment writing” is somewhat of a new form of social writing, I call it short articles. If you look at the comments posted everywhere, some are great and some are horrible.

I started reading comments trying to identify a good way to “comment”. I saw competent comments from about 75 to 100 words long that added to the content and I saw the short “I have raised my hand for recognition” comment. It is like reading a 700 word focused article and commenting with a “Good job Tom” declaration. To bad, I can do about 50 “Good jobs” a day if that would do it for me.

The first question I had to ask myself was, do I really want to write social comments about posted articles? The real questions is why am doing this? My motivation is to gain social and business knowledge and to add my knowledge to the overall knowledge base.

Now that I know why I'm doing this, how do I do this easily and appropriately. To me it is disrespectful to write inappropriately or with bad manners.

I have identified several conditions I observe when writing comments.

I do this voluntarily, I am not required to comment on everything I read. I save my time for commenting about things where I can actually say something useful.

I ask myself, do I know enough about what the article is about to comment?

When I think I can be true to the article;

I read the complete article to provide context for my comment.

I decide what it is that I am responding to in the article.

I select the line or keywords that I want to respond to, and copy to the beginning of my comment. It is usually my comment title. When people come to this page later and read the comments, it will always be immediately clear what I'm talking about. By doing this the comment will always stand out .

I make a point in my comment about the selected line or keyword taken from the article. Then I explain my point or position in context. I may end my comment by asking a question to continue the conversation.

I make my point respectfully and I make only one point per comment. If I have more than one point to make, I make each point a separate comment. Also, I make my comments between 70 and 100 words, short articles, and I proof read – No I Don't – I can't see my own mistakes. I have 2 proof readers.

Its not important to be the first to comment but always present good quality thoughtful comments. Generally, the posts do not go away and a new comment effects the post positively.

I am always careful and thoughtful about what I write. Today, it is required that you guard your social reputation. Your reputation is critical in your success with Social Business Marketing at Markethive.

Louis Harvey Hello Mike, Your article is on point! You have to identify to what the article is about, and want to share your opinion about what the author is trying to convey to his audience thus making it easier to comment on the topic at hand. Its not necessary to comment on all topics all the time unless you have valuable input that you want to add to support whats being shared.
February 10, 2015 at 4:59pm
Mike Prettyman Thanks Brian. When I wrote this, I addressed what I considered the mechanics of writing a comment, a practice I can follow repeatedly and get good results. I wrote with the focus on content and context but when I comment I am in really commenting or talking directly with the author like I am to you now. Its best if you keep in mind not only what you are talking about but to whom you are talking.
February 1, 2015 at 10:23pm
James Eckburg I really like your post. You have said it right and I agree to what you said in the above post. I look forward to work with you in the Market Hive.
January 31, 2015 at 10:33pm
Mike Prettyman Applying this same approach to forums is highly recommended. Tom has started a group WarriorForum Social Club, the purpose is to elaborate and explore the engagement with Warrior Forum.
January 31, 2015 at 6:26pm