Maker: The Topps Company 
Original Price: $9.98/pack*
Worth Today: $7,856*

In GEM MT 10 condition, you could sell your Garbage Pail Kid Nasty Nick #1A for thousands of dollars. The Garbage Pail Kids were a group of sticker trading cards. Made by Topps, they were released the same year as Cabbage Patch Kid dolls, and they were a parody of them. They even got their own movie in 1987.

Nasty Nick was one of the rarest of the Kids. As the top-most card on the deck, many of his cards were printed slightly off-center. Nasty Nick decked out like a vampire holding a blond-haired doll, is even rarer than Adam Bomb, Evil Eddie, and Schizo Fran.