Maker: Hasbro 
Original Price: $8.95*
Worth Today: $2,000*

Rapunzel and My Little Pony did a crossover episode that would later make the toys from that era worth thousands. Rapunzel was a mail-order pony that cost $8.95 and came with two “Horseshoe Points.” Rapunzel, according to the MLP Wikipedia page, is the rarest My Little Pony in America.

She has long, yellow-gold hair with pink streaks and pink tinsel, and her eye color is pale blue. The pink pony’s symbol is Rapunzel standing in a castle tower. The first-generation Rapunzel has hair that is double the length of the hair on regular, non-special-edition My Little Pony dolls.